[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: <eyebeam><blast> Different Web Art

on 2/21/98 8:23 PM Saskia Sassen wrote:

"It seems to me that it is very important to multiply the different 
cultures, subcultures, practices, "nationalities" on the Net. It is, 
right now too 'western" because the western component is massive. There 
are a lot of "others" on the Web, but they are not enough to dissolve 
the westerness of it. And with commercialization raging onwards, this 
will become even more problematic.  I am quite convinced that practice 
will make form on the web."
saskia sassen (I grew up in Latin America so am sensititve to this)

Let me try to respond to this issue brough up by Saskia,  from the 
perspective of Mexico City... "too western" you write/ask/condemn.  And 
you suggest as a reason "because the western component is massive". 
Think of the following additional considerations.  85% of the films 
being shown in Mexico City are from Hollywood. That seems pretty western 
to me, and it's not on the NET. Surveys made recently show that only 12% 
of the people actually prefer Mexican films over the ones made in 
Hollywood (Reforma Newspaper Research). Watching TV is the single 
largest activity in people's free time as reported by this survey. All 
this seems pretty western to me.  So all in all, I believe that there is 
a certain lack of self analysis when we (lets say from Latin America) 
view this massive western influx as if we were victims to this 
situation. I believe we participate quite willingly in making this 
"western" reality part of our own world.

I don't believe there is any conspiracy going on to reduce our non 
western presence on the net. The problems have a much deeper origin, as 
I see it. It has to do with north vs south; poor nations vs. wealthy 
ones. But this not only confined to nations, but also true within the 
confines of western nations themselves. Or do you think that there is 
much difference between the lack of presence of Latin Americans from all 
over the Continent, and the lack of black people from the ghettos across 
the United States. I don't see them being present on the net either, at 
least not in any numbers that equal their representation in society.  So 
what we have is a rich vs poor scenario. Mind you I am not thinking that 
such poverty is expressed solely in terms of money, I am sure there are 
young people on the net that have hardly a dime to call their own. But 
they have a level of education that allows them to travel through 
cyberspace armed with their wits and knowledge instead of funds.  In the 
end it has to do with class.  And this stratification of the net along 
class on a global scope is one of the issues that I find most alarming. 
 It just happens that many of the Nationalities that Saskia brings up, 
fall into this category of classes before the issues of their specific 
cultures becomes the stumbling block to make themselves present on the 

But let me give you some encouraging statistics... albeit modest, but 
they do give us some level of information from which to gleen some 
conclusions.  I started a web site dedicated to photography about three 
years ago ( http://zonezero.com) . From the first moment I wanted this 
web site to be bilingual ( English/Spanish), in spite of the big efforts 
that doing so represented both in terms of productions costs as well and 
the time to do it all. However two years ago when looking at the stats 
of who viewed what, we looked at numbers which were highly discouraging 
in relation to our efforts. Not even 1% of our visitors went to the 
Spanish part and 99.1% to English.

Today with the total number of visitors having increased some twenty 
fold, those that are going to the Spanish section are 20%. So in 
absolute numbers the increase is terrific, and proportional to the 
number of suscribers throughout Latin America to the rest of the world. 
But don't think for a moment that any from the poor masses from our 
Continent are present in this equation. Not yet!  probably in twenty 
years. I still remember when having access to a TV set was as scarce as 
today having a computer and access to the net. I don't have to tell you 
the numbers of people who today have tv sets. So maybe in time things 
will change, if for no better reason that economies are going to be 
highly dependent on this happening and they (governments) will need to 
make the efforts
towards such a goal.

I hope this offers some addditional insight into what is certainly an 
important topic.

All best to you
Pedro Meyer
a critical forum for artistic practice in the network
texts are the property of individual authors
to unsubscribe, send email to eyebeam@list.thing.net
with the following single line in the message body:
unsubscribe eyebeam-list
information and archive at http://www.eyebeam.org
Eyebeam Atelier/X Art Foundation http://www.blast.org